November 11, 2013
Combatant or Alternative
Service Work (ASW) in Canada Civilian Public Service (CPS) in the United States
The Second World War in the
United States and Canada came upon the Mennonite populations unexpectedly, as
did conscription and the need defend our Pacifist beliefs.
Many North American Mennonites
had left Europe, Netherlands and Russia in search of a country where
they would be exempt from military service. WWII brought this dilemma
back into the homes of Mennonites in North America.
Men between the ages of 15 and 35 had a
choice, to make enlist in the war effort or become a Conscientious Objector
(COs).
Entering the war as a combatant
while socially acceptable for none Mennonite society, enlistment meant
rejection by the Mennonite community and family upon their returned home
(Schmidt, 2013) from war. It also meant that
while in overseas service they were without spiritual and family support (Muir, 2013).
Muir (2013) writes that “as
many as 4,500 Canadian Mennonites enlisted in this country’s military forces
between 1939 and 1945 (p. 6).
Mennonite’s made up 63% of the 9,000 COs in Canada in March 1994 (Schmidt,
2013).
Becoming a CO came at a cost as they were ridiculed and treated with contempt
by their none Mennonite friends and neighbours.
They were seen as cowards willing to hide behind the skirts of
women and braver men: letting other risk death to ensure their freedom. The Mennonite COs in Canada also were for the
vast majority of German descent and this compounded the abuse that they
suffered. In Canada COs in Canada were sent to Alternative Service Work camp where,
“They [CO’s] are not allowed to sleep out of camp, except at infrequent intervals, and they work 8 hours per day for 50c, out of which they have to buy everything except food and lodging, and keep their families if they are married.” (Siemens, 2013) COs were to service a four month term in the alternative service camps (Gingerich, 2009)
Mennonite men during WWII could
either:
- Enlist in a just war against a dictator who was killing Mennonites in gas chambers as well as Jews and
- While at war find their spiritual and familiar community conspicuously silent and unsupportive
- Upon return from war face excommunication from the Mennonite Church
Or
- Become a CO and submit to either ASW in Canada or CPS in USA where
- During their period of service they received support both emotionally and physically from their families and church communities while suffering abuse and mistrust from the none Mennonite community.
- When released from service returning to a supportive Mennonite Community and the continued mistrust of the none Mennonite community.
As a Mennonite woman living in
2013 my children and grandchildren are not faced with having to make these same
choices however this may not always be the case. Where do I stand on the issue of
pacifism? I believe that wherever
possible and at whatever cost we need to support peaceful solutions and stand
witness to the cruelty of war giving aid to the oppressed.
And I am troubled by the
challenge C.S. Lewis presents pacifism, that it supports the cause of the
oppressor. That through peaceful action
and standing witness the tyrannical oppressor will move forward the agenda of
war with impunity. Is this not what the world saw in
1994 with the Rwanda Genocide of its Tutsi Population?
Today is Remembrance Day and I
believe we as Mennonites need to continue to struggle with our pacifism and the
impact it has on ourselves and the world for both good and evil.
Grandma Snyder
Gingerich, M. (2009, March). Alternative Service
Work Camps (Canada). Retrieved November 10 2013, from Global Anabaptist
Mennonite Encyclopedia Online:
http://gameo.org/index.php?title=Alternative_Service_Work_Camps_%28Canada%29
Muir, R. (2013). Let nobody judge them. Canadian
Mennonite, 6-11.
Schmidt, M. (2013, November 10). Mennonite WWII
Service Alternative Service. Retrieved from University Fraser Valley:
http://app.ufv.ca/fvhistory/studentsites/wwII/mennonitewwIIservice/alternativeservice.html
Siemens, K. (2013, 11 10). WWII Mennonite Menace.
Retrieved from University Fraser Valley:
http://app.ufv.ca/fvhistory/studentsites/wwII/mennonitemenace/page3.html
Thursday, 31 October 2013
Delving into the past
I work at First Mennonite Church in Kitchener and frequently have people coming into my office looking for the grave site of a relative. Our records are limited, but if someone is buried there I can usually find a location. I've also learned from these people about other on-line tools for finding ancestors.
This got me to thinking about my own great-great grandmother, about whom I knew only a first name. Could I find more?
I started at with a marvellous source, The Eby Book, now kept at the Joseph Schneider Haus in Kitchener. This is a book written by Ezra Eby about 1895, listing the Mennonite family in and around Waterloo Region. From there I discovered EzraEby.com, where Allan Detweiler has done an incredible job continuing the work Ezra started.
I did a search on this site and found my Grandma:
So here is the
original owner of my plate. I do wish I knew more about this woman who
died in 1876, before my Grandma was even born! And about this plate,
which doesn't seem very Amish to me.
As Barbara
Erb's parents were born in Europe (continuing my backward search), did
they bring the plate to the New World? Or was it acquired here? This
record doesn't say if Barbara was born in Wilmot Township, only that she
died here. She was only in her forties when she died. With at least
nine living children the youngest only two years old. How sad.
But as I
clicked on various family members I discovered an interesting fact.
Bishop John P Gascho remarried after his wife's death: to Barbara Erb -
another one!
Were the two
Barbaras related? The second one didn't marry until her forties, never
had children of her own, but took on a big family. And lived to be 96. Was this one the original owner of the plate?
Seems the more questions I get answered the more I have!
Saturday, 26 October 2013A Tour of Waterloo the Joseph B. Snyder Way
We started our tour at the Timeless Café and Bakery at 305
Northfield Dr. East, Waterloo Ontario.
This is the site of Joseph B. & Veronica (Weber) Snyder’s home farm.
The Bakery is in what was Veronica’s chicken coop. The owners of Timeless Café has capitalized
on this. The cutlery comes wrapped in a
paper napkin held together with a chicken sticker and the on the restroom door
is a sign designating Hens and Roosters.
Paul and I had a wonderful meal. I had the daily quiche special, peach, mango
salsa and sautéed onion it tastes much better that the description. Paul had a sautéed onion, mushroom grilled
cheese and again very tasty.
The barn has been converted into The Timeless Material Company where historical building materials, furniture and other decorative artifacts
and recycled are repurposed.
Paul drew my attention to the ramp that was built up to the
barn and the passageway underneath where the Snyder’s would enter the lower
level.
The house appears to be empty. As we walked around the property I imagined
Veronica sitting on the front porch snapping beans or podding peas. Once lunch or supper was ready ringing the
bell on the roof of the house to call her twelve children, husband and hired
men to the house.
Joseph B. Snyder January 20, 1854 – March
25, 1938
Veronica Weber, January 19, 1857 – May 20,
1934
Married December 5, 1876
Children:
Simeon Snyder January 13, 1878 – March 5, 1947
Susannah Snyder August 21, 1879 – March 7,
1882
Leah Snyder February 19, 1882 – August 14, 1957
Lucinda Snyder May 15, 1884 (the historical record that I was working from does
not a date of death)
Lovina Snyder April 28, 1886 – April 19,
1944
Edwin Snyder October 31, 1887 – April 27,
1947
Joseph Snyder August 26, 1889 – March 18,
1935
Anna Snyder July 14, 1891 (the historical
record that I was working from does not a date of death)
Ephriam Snyder July 7, 1894 (the
historical record that I was working from does not a date of death)
Fanny Snyder July 22, 1898 (the
historical record that I was working from does not a date of death)
Moses Snyder May 8, 1900 and died May 8,
1900
Noah Snyder December 29, 1904 – February 9,
1910
Leaving Joseph B. Snyder’s home farm we
turned left onto Northfield Dr. East and then turned right onto Bridge St. At approximately 827 -857 Bridge St. West
there is a bush to your left stop the car and get out. The piece of property on your left is the
Schneider homestead, all that remains is the spring house which you can see in
the bush.
Your next stop is at the St. Jacob
Farmers Market, where Quilted Heirlooms is housed at the onsite log cabin. The cabin was originally built by Joseph E.
Schneider on the spring house property.
Paul is drawing your attention to the size of the logs used. |
It appears that Joseph B. changed the
family name from Schneider to Snyder at a time that coincided with WWII.
This brings to an end our day tour of
historical Snyder family sites.
Grandma Snyder
Monday, 26 August 2013
Responses to Family Reunions
Our
Stories
Yesterday’s blog has created a buzz and I want to share with you some of the stories and comments that
readers have posted to my Facebook account and sent to me via email.
Carol Wagler Bauman wrote:
So...I had a heart-warming experience yesterday. For me,
there will always be a special part in my heart for the place where I was
raised till age 6. That place is Wellesley.
Ever since that time of moving from
Wellesley, I have felt a disconnectedness from my roots. My heart always rushes
when I connect with someone from that area and the "are you related
to..?" questions start rushing out.
There was a new couple at church yesterday and I went and
introduced myself and they told me their first names and told me they were
visiting at the cottage with their son and daughter-in-law. I had just recently
learned the surname if this couple and had been curious about their LEIS name.
That name shouted Wellesley out to me!
And suddenly, I'm presented with an
opportunity to meet Eldon Leis and his wife. I learned that he grew up in my
home church, I learned that he is a well-respected painter (google it), I
learned that his cousin married Duane and I and I learned that indeed, it's a
small world.
Sometimes Mennonites are teased about playing the "name
game". I don't think that's bad. And in light of a cousin's daughter,
Marjorie Klassen, musing that our children are losing the family stories (and
heritage, I would say) I will gladly ask these questions and tell anyone who
will listen to me. And, if I go back far enough I would wager that Eldon Leis
and I have some common blood between us.
I
Googled Eldon Leis and found this very interesting You Tube video he
made. In this video clip he tells us a story about his hobbies and in
the telling he enriches our lives.
Elaine Swartz wrote:
Thanks for including us in your blog. We try to get together
each Christmas.
I
also know that Elaine comes to Ontario every summer to spend a week at
Chesley Lake with her sisters and sister-in-law where they share their
stories with each other.
M.R. wrote:
We have an annual one! With 50 first cousins on one side of
the family - we have become a renter of halls!
Eunice Derowin wrote:
I've
been enjoying your Grandma Snyder blog and wanted to share one of my
(very few) memories of my Grandma Snyder. She came to visit the new
baby (Paul) shortly before she died at age 59. What I remember best is
that like other visitors she brought a gift for the baby, but unlike
them, she also brought a pocketful of candy for the 4 older children.
Eunice
is my sister-in-law and in her sharing this story she enriched my
husband Paul's understanding of and experience with his Grandma Snyder.
This is just a sampling of what I received. As human beings belonging is key to our
survival. We belong to many groups over a life time. Today as I read and responded to readers I came to understand that through this blog we are forming a group and
together we are shaping each other’s understanding of what it means to be
children, parents, grandparents and great grandparents.
If you have a story you would like share
please send it to me and I will consider it for publication on this blog –
there is room for many voices and all of our experiences.
Sunday, 22 September 2013
Angels
A Child learns to Sing
This
morning at church we sang "Have Thine Own Way" #504 in the Mennonite song book Hymnal a Worship Book. As the
hymn started and voices were raised I was transported back 53 years attending
church with Aunt Marjorie at her rural Brethren in Christ Church.
The
sound of shoes on hardwood flooring as the congregation gets ready to
stand and of wooden benches
moving under the relief of people standing.
The
smell of wood polish and stale air escaping through windows only opened on
Sunday morning. The hint of moth balls
on clothing only brought out for Sunday service, weddings and funerals. The absence of the smell of human sweat and
other body smells, all bodies washed and polished for this event.
The
sound of a pitch pipe, a mass intake of breath and a sacred pause. Then the sound of 20 to 50 voices raised in
common praise and a spontaneous smile on a child's face. I do the unthinkable I stand on the wooden
bench, I want to be part of this.
The
sound is not in adherence to the notes on the page rather the music is unique and
created through the out pouring of love escaping the hearts of the singers.
I
add my voice to this choir of human love.
Aunt Marjorie reaches down and takes my hand. I look up into her face. Wisps of her white blond hair have escaped her covering and are
caught in the sunlight streaming through the church windows. It creates a halo
around her face. In that moment I knew
in my spirit that singing transforms us into human angels. Aunt Marjorie smiles at me turns and
continues to sing her love of her Creator.
I
lift my head and confidently add my voice to this choir of human angels, I am 5
years old and this is my first conscious memory of singing in an adult service.
Thank
you Lord for the gift of this memory forgotten until this morning.
Grandma Snyder
No comments:
Post a Comment